The Latest From Larry

 

The Fiscal Times
July 26 2010

Time for an Obama Gut-Check on Taxes
Lawrence J. Haas

President Obama must decide this fall whether to confront not just congressional Republicans but a growing number of Democrats on a key matter of public policy – President George W. Bush’s tax cuts for those at the top.

His decision will have enormous implications for fiscal policy, with hundreds of billions of dollars in potential deficit savings at stake. It will also have a profound impact on Obama’s future relations with Capitol Hill.

For Obama, however, the issue is even bigger. Here’s the question (a version of which every president eventually faces):

Will Obama draw a line in the sand that he will not cross, making clear what he supports and what he does not in this crucial election year, regardless of the consequences?

The nation’s leading newspapers (New York Times, Washington Post, and Wall Street Journal) in the last two days have focused mostly on the debate brewing in Congress. Republican lawmakers uniformly favor permanently extending all of President Bush’s tax cuts from 2001 and 2003, which are due to expire at the end of 2010, while many Democrats would let the tax cuts expire for the wealthiest Americans.

Obama’s decision-making has received less attention. But, he has the power to bend the issue to his liking, depending on how he plays his cards.

Obama’s policy is clear: he has proposed extending the tax cuts for those making up to $250,000 a year and letting them expire for the 2 percent of taxpayers above that level. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, Obama’s lead spokesperson on the issue, has reiterated that stance in recent days.

But the economic recovery remains weak and a growing number of moderate Democrats, such as Senate Budget Committee Chairman Kent Conrad, say that, this fall, they want to extend all of the Bush tax cuts at least temporarily, avoiding a tax increase on anyone that, they believe, would threaten the economy.

Liberals, however, fear that if this Congress extends all of the tax cuts for, say, a year or two this fall as part of a bipartisan deal to avoid a Republican filibuster, they won’t be able to stop the next Congress, which will probably have many more Republicans in it, from making them all permanent.

With far more than the 40 votes needed to block legislation in the Senate, Republicans in the next Congress will insist that a bill to make tax cuts permanent for everyone up to $250,000, as the White House and most Democrats will push, be extended to make all of the tax cuts permanent.

But the debate need not get that far. This fall, the President can dig in his heels, making clear to Republicans and to Democrats like Conrad that he simply won’t sign legislation to extend tax cuts for those at the top – even if it’s part of a larger bill to extend tax cuts to the other 98 percent of Americans.

He can say that, with deficits and debt due to explode in the coming years, we simply can’t afford to extend tax cuts for those who don’t need them. Moreover, extending tax cuts for those at the top won’t help the economy anyway because the well-to-do would likely save rather than spend the money.

The president can argue that if lawmakers believe the economy needs another short-term jolt of fiscal stimulus, he would be happy to work with them to apply the short-term savings from denying an extension of the tax cuts to the wealthiest Americans to more effective stimulus measures, as former Federal Reserve Vice Chairman Alan Blinder recently advocated.

Presidents face these moments from time to time – moments when they must oppose not only the "loyal opposition" but members of their own party, moments when the Oval Office is a lonely place indeed.

President Truman faced it over Israel, when his legendary Secretary of State, George C. Marshall, and most of his foreign policy team argued strenuously that he should not recognize the new state, which he did anyway shortly after its creation.

President Johnson faced it over civil rights and Vietnam, both of which opened fissures within the Democratic party that would pave the way for Republican victories for years to come in once-safe Democratic areas.

President George W. Bush faced it over Iraq, when growing numbers of members within his own party began to echo Democratic calls to retreat before he ignored them and sent more troops to quell the chaos.

History has treated Truman well over Israel, and Johnson well over civil rights. The jury is out for Bush over Iraq.

It’s gut-check time for Obama. History can wait. The world will soon see whether he feels strongly about who should get more tax cuts and who should not.

 

Copyright The Fiscal Times 2010

 

 

 










replace with your keywords

Most Recent Writing

The Fiscal Timesl
July 23 2010
The Vicious Cycle of Fiscal Incoherence   

The Fiscal Timesl
July 20 2010
What Would GOP Gains in November Mean   

The Fiscal Timesl
July 13 2010
Deficit-Cutting, Consensus, and Crisis   

The Fiscal Timesl
June 28 2010
G-20 May Signal Turning Point   

North Star National
June 23 2010
America must protect a hero     

North Star National
May 27 2010
American ideology, American pragmatism    

North Star National
May 14 2010
Time to discard Middle East mythologies     

Henry Jackson Society
Winter
2010
LETTER FROM WASHINGTON/ Adventures in Engagement

North Star National
May 5 2010
Poor Franklin, poor Eleanor    

North Star National
April 23 2010
With Iran, the war is now    

North Star National
April 12 2010
Obama’s nuke strategy: Do the rogues really care about "engagement"?   

North Star National
March 31 2010
Sleepwalking toward a nuclear Iran  

North Star National
March 26 2010
The United States of Intolerance  

North Star National
March 18 2010
Of human rights and glass houses  

North Star National
March 11 2010
Greece’s window on America  

North Star National
March 4 2010
The horrors of life in North Korea 

North Star National
February 26 2010
Obama and the perils of leadership

North Star National
February 17 2010
Evan Bayh’s departure, and some historical context for just how "broken" things really are

North Star National
February 9 2010
Iran’s tipping point?

North Star National
February 2 2010
Washington D.C.: A tale of two cities

Henry Jackson Society
Winter
2010
LETTER FROM WASHINGTON/OBAMA AND HUMAN RIGHTS: Hitting the "Reset Button

North Star National
January 19 2010
The best budget speech that you’ll never hear

North Star National
January 11 2010
The Fiscal Times: The future is now

North Star National
January 6 2010
Harold Meyerson’s Misguided Lament

North Star National
December 15 2009
Obama steps up in Oslo

North Star National
December 9 2009
The latest from Ahmadinejad

North Star National
December 1 2009
Beware of Lou Dobbs and the politics of anger

North Star National
November 23 2009
Career advice for men and women alike

North Star National
November 16, 2009
Wafa Sultan and the nature of Islam

North Star National
November 10, 2009
Fort Hood and the rush to non-judgment

North Star National
November 5, 2009
Election 2009: Another pendulum swing, and again, the nation's business goes undone

North Star National
October 28, 2009
Another look at the Iran Hostage Crisis

North Star National
October 19, 2009
Coming soon from Washington: More freebies, more red ink

North Star National
October 15, 2009
America's future: It's in our hands

North Star National
October 7, 2009
Inside Ahmadinejad’s Mind

North Star National
September 30, 2009
Protect free expression

North Star National
September 25, 2009
Iran: Obama's getting it, but it's time to go all the way and support freedom for the people

North Star National
September 20, 2009
“Thank God for Israel”

North Star National
September 13, 2009
Ilan Berman’s “Winning the Long War”: A comprehensive strategy for fighting terrorism

North Star Writers Group
September 8, 2009
Obama Talks to Kids, Wing Nuts Erupt

North Star Writers Group
September 1, 2009
Remembering Kennedy, and Cooling the Rhetoric

North Star Writers Group
August 11, 2009
Higher Taxes Are Coming, As They Should

North Star Writers Group
August 4, 2009
Reading Obama’s Mind (Optimistically): Middle East Game Plans

North Star Writers Group
August 4, 2009
Reading Obama’s Mind (Optimistically): Middle East Game Plans

North Star Writers Group
July 28, 2009
For Democrats, Raging Incrementalism May Be the Answer

North Star Writers Group
July 21, 2009
America’s Cycles: The Moon, ‘Malaise’ and Free Berlin!

North Star Writers Group
July 14, 2009
Iran: Of Courage and Cowardice

North Star Writers Group
July 7, 2009
Two-State Delusions in the Middle East

North Star Writers Group
June 30, 2009
America’s Human Rights Challenges Extend Beyond Iran

North Star Writers Group
June 23, 2009
Iran’s Turmoil May Prove Convenient for Obama

North Star Writers Group
June 9, 2009
Needed: A New Imperative to Cut the Deficit

North Star Writers Group
June 2, 2009
Three Ways Obama Must Choose Wisely in Cairo

North Star Writers Group
May 26, 2009
On Taxes and Spending, Democrats Must Not Ignore Public Skepticism

North Star Writers Group
May 19, 2009
Burma’s Aung San Suu Kyi: Diplomacy, Human Rights – And a Brave Woman

North Star Writers Group
May 12, 2009
U.S. Takes Risky Approach to Iran and the Middle East

North Star Writers Group
May 5, 2009
Media Under Assault, Freedom Suffers

North Star Writers Group
April 28, 2009
The Cost of Capitalism: We’re Having a Minsky Moment

North Star Writers Group
April 21, 2009
UN's Durban II a Disgrace, But Also a Welcome Wake-Up Call

North Star Writers Group
April 14, 2009
The Sad (and False) Tales of Victims of the Estate Tax

North Star Writers Group
April 7, 2009
Obama Puts Global Engagement to the Test

North Star Writers Group
March 31, 2009
Reading Obama's Mind: Some Job This Is!

North Star Writers Group
March 17, 2009
The Problem With Budget Deficits

North Star Writers Group
March 10, 2009
Charles Freeman, America's Next Political Rorschach Test 

DEMOCRATIYA
Spring-Summer
2009

Letter from Washington / Don't Bet on America's Decline

North Star Writers Group
March 3, 2009
Combating Anti-Semitism: It's About Time

North Star Writers Group
February 24, 2009
Budget Commission? Bad Idea; Responsible Budgeting is Congress's Job

North Star Writers Group
February 17, 2009
Terrorists Fight Back With 'Libel Tourism'

North Star Writers Group
February 10, 2009
Don Alexander: A Man for Our Time

North Star Writers Group
January 27, 2009
Dutch Debacle: Orwell Lives in Geert Wilders Free Speech Case

North Star Writers Group
January 20, 2009
Obama Needs a Narrative on Free Trade

North Star Writers Group
January 13, 2009
Who Cares for the Gazans? How About Israel?

North Star Writers Group
January 06, 2009
British Strike Back Against Hitler; Today's Media, Human Rights Groups Weigh In

North Star Writers Group
December 30, 2008
Public Diplomacy: America's Embarrassing Failure to Take Its Message to the World

North Star Writers Group
December 23, 2008
The Pathetic Rick Sanchezation of America

North Star Writers Group
December 16, 2008
For Obama, Defending America's Interests Means Beware of Durban II

MORE.....